vovchik_ilich [he/him]

  • 0 Posts
  • 24 Comments
Joined 9 months ago
cake
Cake day: August 14th, 2024

help-circle














  • “Your analysis should stop where I say it should stop” isn’t the greatest way of approaching someone on your side of the struggle. We’re all buddies here, no need to be so aggressive.

    “goodness of their hearts” more moralist idealist nonsense

    When the USSR didn’t engage in unequal exchange once it was industrialised, it was literally out of moral principles. When Cuba sends doctors abroad to crises, it’s literally out of moral principles. It isn’t “idealist nonsense”, the struggle against imperialism essentially stems from morality, trying to separate the two is absurd.

    You are not a marxist, this is not marxist analysis

    Again, I ask you to refrain from engaging in offensive statements. Hexbear is cool, I don’t want it to be an aggressive poison swamp.

    The same exact argument could be made for Rachel Corrie going and dying under Israeli bulldozer treads to protect a “capitalist” and “reactionary” nation of Palestine.

    Palestine can’t be compared to Russia because Palestine isn’t an industrialised nation. The difference between Russia and Palestine is rhat Russia is industrialised and can therefore engage in imperialism, and it does. Palestine, as a colony undergoing genocide, is in a very, very different position.

    My whole point is that critical support to Russia is OK, I’m not arguing against that. My point is that there are a million more effective and more moral ways of engaging in anti-imperialism than sacrificing your life for the Russian oligarchs just because they happen to currently engage in warfare against the imperialist west.


  • Russia is acting in Ukraine essentially the only way it’s been allowed to, in order to maintain its sphere of economic and diplomatic influence around it, it has been essentially forced by the imperialist west to engage in warfare.

    The fact that Russia is in a geopolitical position opposed to the west, means that, in a general sense, the fight is anti-western imperialism. It also can be described as Russian capitalist imperialism though, it’s not for the goodness of its heart that it’s engaging in this struggle against the west, it’s for the sake of the profits of its capitalists.

    That’s not nearly enough reason, as a westerner, to go throw your body into the meat grinder for a country actively oppressing its minorities, its women, and its LGTBQ. There’s plenty more ways you can engage in anti-imperialism such as donating money to Cuba or time in mutual aid. I don’t see how that’s a chauvinist point of view: I can recognise that the west is actively worse than Russia in terms of imperialism (even if only by the fact that it holds more geopolitical and economical power), and that there are way more effective and less morally reprehensible ways of anti-imperialist struggle.