There are probably more people with tetanus than there are trans college athletes. There’s literally only 10 of them. It is by definition a moral panic. The people crying about it are lying and evil.
I’d be shocked if there’s only 10 trans college athletes. My college fencing club had three I could name, 15 years ago. My current college has at least one.
Now, out trans women who competed in NCAA sports, certainly a smaller set of people.
Also, totes agree it’s ridiculous to care about (I don’t know how to call it) the “integrity” of college women’s sports more than something that is actually harming and killing kids.
Here’s something more shocking: While we’re all debating the pressing issue of [insert current debate], let’s not forget the far more pressing matters like the fact that burning brown coal kills 32.72 people per terawatt-hour of electricity. But hey, priorities, right?
Okay? Who cares? If 60% of college athletes were transgender it doesn’t change the fact this is fascist biological essentialism and explicitly exists to harm those it targets. You are trying to create a spectre that does not exist. Stop acting like it matters what number of trans athletes this harms.
I care! I was one of the 3 trans people in the fencing club and I really dislike being told there are so few “trans college athletes” that I was about 10% of the total (assuming the prevalence of trans college athletes has remained constant from 15 years ago to today).
I don’t find it useful to quote statistics without recognizing their sources and limitations. It leads to inaccurate perceptions of reality.
The inaccurate perception is pretending like any amount of political will should be expended on barring trans people from school sports regardless of how many there are.
Congrats on your personal experience it does not change the fact that this is fucking stupid. Fencing is not an NCAA sport you’re just doing agitprop for fascists by implying that a fencing club is the same as a sanctioned competitive sport jesus fucking christ. You also are not speaking for all trans people by pointing out your experience of being overrepresented in YOUR school fencing club that is not subject to oversight by the governing sports body FIFTEEN YEARS AGO.
I’m quoting the person in charge of the organization and youre quoting a personal anecdote that is fifteen years old. Who is skewing perception of the current state of collegiate athletics?
It was a club sport and counted as a PE class for college credit.
I get that the NCAA doesn’t cover clubs, but the image and parent comment didn’t specify NCAA sanctioned sports.
There are probably more people with tetanus than there are trans college athletes. There’s literally only 10 of them. It is by definition a moral panic. The people crying about it are lying and evil.
I’d be shocked if there’s only 10 trans college athletes. My college fencing club had three I could name, 15 years ago. My current college has at least one.
Now, out trans women who competed in NCAA sports, certainly a smaller set of people.
Also, totes agree it’s ridiculous to care about (I don’t know how to call it) the “integrity” of college women’s sports more than something that is actually harming and killing kids.
Here’s something more shocking: While we’re all debating the pressing issue of [insert current debate], let’s not forget the far more pressing matters like the fact that burning brown coal kills 32.72 people per terawatt-hour of electricity. But hey, priorities, right?
I’m getting that number from the president of the NCAA
From https://www.kget.com/sports/ncaa-president-says-there-are-less-than-10-transgender-athletes-in-college-sports/ ? That’s the number the head of the NCAA is aware of, and almost certainly doesn’t cover college athletes playing on non-NCAA teams and sports.
Okay? Who cares? If 60% of college athletes were transgender it doesn’t change the fact this is fascist biological essentialism and explicitly exists to harm those it targets. You are trying to create a spectre that does not exist. Stop acting like it matters what number of trans athletes this harms.
I care! I was one of the 3 trans people in the fencing club and I really dislike being told there are so few “trans college athletes” that I was about 10% of the total (assuming the prevalence of trans college athletes has remained constant from 15 years ago to today).
I don’t find it useful to quote statistics without recognizing their sources and limitations. It leads to inaccurate perceptions of reality.
The inaccurate perception is pretending like any amount of political will should be expended on barring trans people from school sports regardless of how many there are.
Congrats on your personal experience it does not change the fact that this is fucking stupid. Fencing is not an NCAA sport you’re just doing agitprop for fascists by implying that a fencing club is the same as a sanctioned competitive sport jesus fucking christ. You also are not speaking for all trans people by pointing out your experience of being overrepresented in YOUR school fencing club that is not subject to oversight by the governing sports body FIFTEEN YEARS AGO.
I’m quoting the person in charge of the organization and youre quoting a personal anecdote that is fifteen years old. Who is skewing perception of the current state of collegiate athletics?
Is fencing a club sport at your school or an NCAA sanctioned sport?
It was a club sport and counted as a PE class for college credit. I get that the NCAA doesn’t cover clubs, but the image and parent comment didn’t specify NCAA sanctioned sports.